The November, 2011 Newsletter October was a busy month here at The Eclectic Angler! And just when we were starting to get dug out, the big Nor'easter hit last Friday and dumped 14" of snow on us. We've been without telephone, internet and cable until this afternoon and our electricity has been off and on during this time. Looks like things are getting back to normal now and we've put the final polish on this month's Newsletter.
We are doing something new with our Tip and Reelflections columns this month - you'll be able to download them as PDF files to print and save for future use. The formatting might be a little nicer in the PDF versions too. Also, we've added a new feature - video! We've created a YouTube channel, www.youtube.com/user/TheEclecticAngler, and have short video companions for our Engine Turning tip and our Reelflections column.
 The other big news item this month is the publication of John Betts' new book Reels & Making Them, scheduled to ship on the 17th of November. It has been over a year since we started the electronic publishing project and now that is complete. We've had lots of requests for a printed edition and here it is. The book has 450 handwritten pages, over 500 color photographs and illustrations, and 100 copies will be signed and numbered by the author. We've also created a new publishing division called Reel Lines Press to publish this and several other books we have in the works. Reels & Making Them is published in association with The Whitefish Press and we will be collaborating on future projects and offering books from each other's catalogs.
Tip #11 this month covers Engine Turning - a technique for creating an eye-catching pattern of swirls on your reels. Along with the article, there is also a video companion to show how its done. To celebrate John Betts' book, Reelflections takes a look at one of his reels in detail - including its interesting click check. We've created ashort video so you can hear it in action.
Table of Contents
- November Specials
- Reelsmithing Workshops
- Tip #11 - Engine Turning Reel Components
- Reelflections - A John Betts Reel
If you have an article request or would like to submit a story or tip to the newsletter, please contact me at mhackney@eclecticangler.com.
Did you know that back issues of The Eclectic Angler Newsletter are online? They contain lots of great tips and other information.
November SpecialsOur Materials Package and "The Reelsmith Primer" and Materials Package combo are 25% off this Month!
November is a great time to make a reel for yourself, spouse, child, grandchild or friend! Our Materials Package makes it easy, all of the hardware and materials you need plus a set of drawings and templates. These packages are designed to accompany our book, The Reelsmith's Primer, but an enterprising reelsmith can use them to get off to a great start. There are no coupons, the 25% discount has already been applied in our store. All orders will include one of our new Nipper Zingers as a bonus.
Reelsmithing WorkshopsWe have several Reelsmithing Workshops coming up over the winter months and other events will be added.
- Saturday, November 12 from 11 am to 2 pm at The Arts of the Angler show in Danbury, Ct. Space is still available and this is a great event sponsored by theCatskill Fly Fishing Center and Museum.
- We are working with the folks at Rose River Farm in Virginia to plan a very specialReelsmithing Workshop and Fly Fishing Weekend at the farm. This will occur sometime in January or Fenbruary, perfect months for fishing at the farm! Contact Rose River for more information and registration.
- We are also putting together another Workshop in conjunction with the New Hampshire Council of Trout Unlimited following the great success we had last year. Our workshop raised $500 for the Council's Trout in the Classroom project. We are planning to make an even larger donation this year. Watch an upcoming Newsletter for dates and more information.
TipsA PDF version of this tip and accompanying video can be found here: Tip #11 - Engine Turning Reel Parts
Our tip this month describes a technique to add an eye-catching decorative touch to your aluminum or brass reels. The technique is called “engine turning” or “jeweling” and has been used for several centuries to add a decorative element to metal surfaces. A famous example of engine turning is the engine cowl on Charles Lindburgh’s Spirit of St. Louis (see Figure 1). The technique can be applied quite effectively to brass and aluminum fly reels. Figure 2 is a jeweled reel made by my friend Wayne Caron. Wayne first introduced me to engine turning a few years ago.
 Figure 1 – Spirit of St. Louis (photo in public domain)
 Figure 2 – Wayne Caron’s Engine Turned Reel (photo used with permission)
Tip #11 – Engine Turning (aka Jeweling) Reel parts Engine turning is complicated looking but surprisingly easy to create and it doesn’t require a lot of special tooling. The technique creates a highly ornamental swirled pattern produced by lightly touching the metal surface with a spinning a brush (or other abrasive element) in a drill press. The part is then shifted slightly (usually about ½ the diameter of the swirl pattern) and another swirl applied. Continuing this produces a fish scale like series of swirls.
There is lots of information on the Web about engine turning and jeweling with some beautiful examples. However, almost all of the information I found applied a linear pattern. Since reels are round, I wanted to develop a process for applying a concentric pattern of swirls and that is what I’ll describe.
We’ve also prepared a short video to accompany this tip! You can find it on our YouTube channel at www.youtube.com/user/TheEclecticAngler.
Engine Turning Tools As mentioned above, the only tools required are a drill press and a spinning abrasive, typically a brush. Nylon, brass and stainless steel bristled brushes are commonly used and create different effects based on the stiffness of the bristle. Common pencil erasers and other abrasive rubber rods can also be used. With both types of tools, the effect can be enhanced by using an abrasive suspended in light oil. Pumice and silicon carbide are common and work well.
Although it is possible to apply the pattern with a handheld electric or even hand cranked drill, a drill press gives more control and more uniformity to the pattern. A simple drill press attachment for a common hand drill is perfect for this technique.
I like to use stainless steel bristled brushes (Figure 3) on both aluminum and brass. The smaller the diameter of the brush, the smaller the pattern it creates. On small items like fishing reels, smaller patterns are more eye-catching than larger swirls. The brush can also mushroom as it is pressed against the metal, increasing the diameter of the swirl. I’ll discuss how to control that a little later.
 Figure 3 - Stainless Steel Brush
I like the 3/16” diameter stainless steel brushes offered by Brownells for engine turning guns. Dremel makes suitable 3/16” diameter brushes with nylon (#405), brass (#537), and stainless steel (#532). I’ve read that normal carbon steel brushes can leave particles embedded in aluminum that will rust. The brushes are inexpensive so it is best to avoid that potential problem by using stainless steel brushes.
You can use the brushes as-is but I find that mushrooming of the bristles results in inconsistent swirl patterns that are usually larger than what I want. So, I prepare my brushes by wrapping the bristles tightly with a layer of masking tape, leaving about 1/8” of bristle exposed. Then, a short length of heat shrink tubing is slid over the masking tape and shrunk. I usually use 2 layers of heat shrink to give a very rigid brush that maintains a consistent and small diameter. Figure 4 shows the wrapped brush.
 Figure 4 - Wrapped Steel Brush
To get an even, concentric pattern of swirls, I use the simple fixture shown in Figure 5. It is constructed from a 6” x 6” piece of board (plywood, particle or pine) with a ¼” pivot mounted in a ¼” hole in its center. The pivot in my fixture is brass but a ¼” wood dowel rod works fine. The spool plate – with its ¼” center hole – rotates on this pivot to keep the concentric pattern uniform.
 Figure 5 - Engine Turning Fixture
Engine Turning Before starting, clean and polish your part. Although engine turning will hide some surface imperfections, a polished surface produces a better result. I sand to 600 grit and polish with Flitz™ metal polish.
(The following description is for a right handed drill press and operator.)
- I use an X-Y table on my drill press to position the work but simply moving the fixture and clamping to the drill press table works fine. Start by chucking the brush and then positioning the fixture’s pivot directly under the brush. Then, slide the fixture to the left until the bristles will just graze the pivot. Clamp the fixture down or lock your X-Y table. Figure 6 shows the initial setup. With an X-Y table, you simple turn the X handle and remember how far you turned it. You’ll use this X movement for all remaining concentric rings.
- Now, position the spool plate over the pivot. You can start by engine turning the backside of the rear spool plate for practice. No one will see it! Make sure the spool plate rotates freely on the pivot and ream the plate’s center hole if not. Use a medium to fast spindle speed on your drill press.
- Hold the spool plate firmly against the table with your left hand and slowly lower the brush using the drill press’ quill until it just touches the surface of the part. Check the swirl pattern to see if you are getting the effect you want. If not, repeat but apply more pressure with the quill. Once I have the pattern I want, I use my quill depth lock to make sure it is repeatable but you can do it by feel also.
- With the first swirl mark made, rotate the part clockwise until the edge of the brush passes over the middle of the previous swirl – this is ½ of the swirl diameter and gives a pleasing pattern. See Figure 7 for example. The reason for rotating the part clockwise is so you can see the previously applied swirl and can use it to lineup the position of the brush. Apply the new swirl and then repeat Step 4 until you’ve gone almost all the way around the part.
- At the end of the circular row of swirls, you may need to fudge the swirl overlap a little to get the pattern to line up at the ends, but you don’t need to be too persnickety since it is difficult to see minor variations in the swirl pattern when complete.
- Once the circular row of swirls is complete, you move the fixture and part ½ a swirl diameter to the left to create the next row. I like to start the next row so the new swirl is in the valley between 2 swirls in the previous row. However, since the diameter of the row increases as you move to the perimeter of the spool plate, each successive row will have a few more swirls than the previous row. Simply do a ½ swirl overlap as you progress around the row and it will turn out all right.
- Repeat steps 4 through 6 until you have completed engine turning the part, as in Figure 8.
 Figure 6 - Initial Setup
 Figure 7 - Swirl Pattern Overlap
 Figure 8 - Completed Engine Turning
Finish by cleaning the part is soapy water, drying and then applying a good wax. I like to engine turn both the outside and inside surfaces of the spool plates but you can engine turn one face and leave the other plain – it’s your reel! Figure 9 is the spool plate installed on the reel.
 Figure 9 - Completed Reel with Engine Turned Spool Plate
ReelflectionsA John Betts ReelA PDF version and accompanying video can be found here: Reelflections 11/2011 - A John Betts Reel
With the publication of John Betts’ book, Reels & Making Them, this month, I thought it appropriate to feature one of John’s reels in Reelflections.
John Betts started making fly reels in 1987, experimenting with aluminum, brass and wood in pursuit of attractive, functional, and easy to construct designs. Along the path he’s developed many innovative designs and fabrication techniques, now documented in his book.
I first learned of John’s reelmaking from the text in the first, self-published, edition of his book Making Strip-built Fly Rods. In the Preface, John writes;
“After the hooks came reels of aluminum, brass, or wood...”
and;
“All were begun using only hand tools (no electricity) except the rods which involved a band saw and lathe from the start.”
and finally;
“Parts for the 1st reels were made with a hacksaw, wood rasp, milling file, and hand crank drill. They were polished with a rag rubbed with emery, and then one using tripoli. The tools were as they were because I had not others. The ‘anti-reverse’ on the reel was made from electric lamp parts. Its design is sensitive to 8x, it is still the smoothest I’ve ever used.”
This caught my attention, I had been working on building a fly reel off and on for a few years and these words armed me with the knowledge I needed; that one could actually build a fly reel and without power tools. I tracked down John’s phone number and called to ask about his reelmaking methods. He gave me a few insights and ideas - neither of us realizing that we would collaborated on publishing Reels & Making Them a few years later.
The story continues when Making Strip-built Fly Rods was re-published by Frank Amato Publications. This edition concluded with 2 pages of color photographs of many of John’s reels. This was the first time I got to see his wonderful designs. I’d heard descriptions of his frame designs, fabrication techniques, and click check mechanism but had not actually seen them.
Then in July 2011, on my way to the Colorado Rodmaker’s Gathering to conduct a Reelsmithing Workshop, I took the opportunity to visit and meet John face-to-face for the first time. We spent a wonderful afternoon talking about almost everything, and especially reelbuilding. I got to see his small workshop and tools and the shelf displaying many of his reels - including his wood Aerials - each neatly tagged with a detailed description. I was able to scrutinize each reel as John described it in more detail. Then, unexpectedly, John handed me a reel and told me I could have it. I was elated and honored to be entrusted with his creation. The reel is shown in Figure 1and its tag in Figure 2.
 Figure 1 - John Betts handcrafted reel
 Figure 2 - Description tag attached to reel
The reel is about 2.8” diameter and constructed of brass and stainless steel. The reel was John’s seventh and is described on page 3-15 of Reels & Making Them. John’s description;
“This was a transitional reel. The stamped frame rings were still used. The underside of the reel foot was hammered to give slide bands a better grip - bad idea as it distorted the metal. The spool plates were solid, turned round against the sanding disc on the belt/disc sander. The tolerance between the spool plate and the ring pretty good for a first try (before sanding less than 1/100”).”
The tag also points out that the reel features a “6 click spool” and has several store bought components. Of course, this would not be a Reelflections column without taking a closer look and a peek inside the reel, so let’s dig in.
To start, one of the interesting and attractive features of the reel is its six 1/8” brass pillars as shown in Figure 3 (there are 2 similar pillars opposite the top 2). You may also notice that the front and back frame rings have stainless “line guards”. The back actually has two to make a pocket for the back spool plate.
 Figure 3 - Six pillar construction
The handle is a simple brass tube with a bolster made from an off-the-shelf brass trim washer. Opposite the handle is a counter weight fabricated from a brass acorn nut and another trim washer. Attractive, functional, and simple to construct.
Figure 4 shows John’s Celtic cross back plate and the click check disk. Each of the six peripheral screws attaches to one of the pillars. The bottom arm of the cross is extended and bent to make the reel foot, all in a single piece of brass.The tolerances on this reel are very tight as evidenced by the very small gap between the spool plates and frame rings.
Disassembly starts with removal of the brass spool retaining screw and spool, shown inFigure 5. This retaining mechanism is interesting in itself. A short (~ 3/16”) section of threaded aluminum 1/4” rod (same diameter as the spindle) is threaded on the screw. It mates with the spindle attached to the back plate and is trimmed to length to allow the spool to rotate freely but without excess slop. A brass trim washer provides a nice little detail and hides the two nylon washers below it. This is a very creative solution to the problem of getting the spindle just the right length. The short aluminum section can be trimmed to fit or replaced if made too short without affecting the spindle length or requiring removal of it.
 Figure 4 - Celtic cross back plate
 Figure 5 - Disassembly
The back spool plate in Figure 5 shows how it is attached to the nylon arbor with three flat head screws. It also shows the three holes for the novel click mechanism described next.
The click check on this reel is integrated in to the spool and consists of three spring-loaded nylon “pawls” that “tick” as they cross over two indentations in the click plate. These indentations are shown in Figure 6. The click plate is captured between the Celtic cross and spindle and is held in place by the spindle retaining screw.
 Figure 6 - Click plate detail
John calls this a “6 click spool” since 3 pawls click over 2 indents (3 x 2 = 6) making 6 clicks per revolution. The click has a very distinctive and satisfying sound.
Figure 7 shows a single pawl removed from its hole in the nylon arbor.
 Figure 7 - Location of click pawls in spool
One end of the pawl is mushroomed (the end closest to the spool) and presses against a small spring nested in the bottom of the hole. The arrangement of the spring and mushroomed end of the nylon pawl can be more clearly seen in Figure 8. You can also see the end of an installed pawl protruding from the spool. The spring is a little over 1/4” long.
 Figure 8 - Click pawl detail
The completed reel meets John’s goals of being attractive, functional and easy to construct with limited tools. I promised John that I will fish with it and let him know what I think. I can say that this reel holds an honored position in my reel display.
|
|